On My Mind
  • HOME
  • MORALITY
  • SCRIPTURE
  • PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
  • CHURCH HISTORY
  • BOOKS
  • LITURGY
  • ON MY MIND
  • The Boys of Aroma Hill-Callicoon
  • ABOUT THE BREWMASTER
  • CATHOLIC NOVELS
  • Book Reviews Adult Education

​CATHOLIC NOVELS 

The Power and the Glory [1940] Graham Greene

10/17/2026

0 Comments

 
Throughout my Catholic life the novel The Power and the Glory [1940] has frequently been brought up in discussions of contemporary Catholic writing, though in a controversial sort of way. One reason is the author himself, the English man of letters and Catholic convert, Graham Greene, whose challenging insights into humanity, often in a Catholic cast, caused distemper for reasons that will become clear as we progress in our discussion. Another reason is the character of the [fictional] Mexican priest himself around whom the book pivots. People who know nothing of Greene or the book may have come across the cleric’s nickname in time, “the whiskey priest.” And yet another disconcerting thrust of the book is the glaring distance between the priest’s ungodly life, on the one hand, and his devotion to sacramental duty under threat of death on the other.
 
I have read three of Greene’s 25 novels, and each has impacted me but in three different directions. The first was The Quiet American [1955], which captivated my historical interests. [See my Amazon review here.] The Quiet American is set in Viet Nam, in 1954 where an aging and weary British war reporter with a mistress and easy access to opium covers the fall of the French at Dien Bien Phu. The title of the novel is satire; as France is being driven out of Viet Nam, the U.S. is beginning covert operations under the direction of a young idealist who, as you may have guessed, runs his mouth way too much. The tragedies that follow lead the war reporter to reexamine his life, his profession, and his marriage. This book was made into a movie twice, in 1958 and again in 2002; the latter is considered a closer rendering of Greene’s intent.
 
The End of the Affair [1951] involves “adultery, jealousy, faith, and love during and after World War II” per Chatbox. It, too, was made into a movie twice [1955 and 1999]. I found a very subtle but constant religious undertone that came to flower at the end of the story. With Greene, nothing comes easy, nor does the faith of his subjects pass easily to conscience and understanding.
 
BUT THE POWER AND THE GLORY IS DIFFERENT
 
Greene authored many novels during his long life, but it is hard to argue that any of them is more existentially troubling than The Power and the Glory. Greene was a thinker; he lived through two world wars; he converted to Catholicism as part of his preparation to marry his Catholic bride, Vivian. He wasn’t the poster child for strict observance, and he referred to himself as a “Catholic agnostic” in later years. Despite that—maybe because of that—he produced the most identifiably Catholic novel of the twentieth century.
 
What is The Power and the Glory about? The book is set in Mexico in the 1920’s. We think of Mexico as a Catholic country, and that was true at the time of the book’s narrative. However, a revolution of sorts brought to power an anti-Catholic government under the dictator Plutarco Elias Calles. Although the novel does not analyze the causes, a reader may recognize political patterns in which the aristocrats in the big cities [Catholic] came to be hated in a climate where the gap between rich and poor was markedly obvious. Similar eruptions occurred in late eighteenth century Catholic France where the royalty [Catholic] was overthrown, or in early twentieth century when Lenin suppressed the Russian Orthodox Church.
 
Calles does not appear in the book, but in snatches of brief conversations we hear his intent. Calles believed that his nation was desperately in need of social reform; he was a strong advocate of state-controlled schools which put him at odds with Church leaders. He did not persecute Catholics per se, but set out to kill the ordained priests, assuming that once the local shepherds were gone there would be more embrace of a centralized reform emanating from the federal government.
 
Persecution of priests began wholesale in 1924 and continued till around 1930. Greene located his story within that period. There is much we are never told about the Whiskey Priest. We do learn that he is surreptitiously moving about the jungle areas far from Mexico City, gradually making his way north to safer territory, that a small unit of Mexican troops is seeking to capture him, and the priest is ministering to very remote clusters of Catholics desperate for Confession and the Eucharist.
 
The heart of the novel’s drama is the inner struggle of the priest himself, and to the reader coming upon him for the first time, he is the soul of contradictions. There are significant clues that his past years as a priest have been hardly exemplary. His alcohol abuse did not develop overnight nor was he in any particular hurry to relinquish the bottle. In most every village where he took shelter, someone supplied him with brandy, usually, and certainly other pleasures of the flesh as well. In one village he discovers he has a seven-year-old daughter from an earlier evening of intimacy. The girl’s mother, beholding the Whiskey Priest and his present state of drunken decline, becomes truly angry. “And to think that seven years ago I was proud to be called the priest’s woman.” I suspect, though, that the jungle hinterlands probably did not receive the most promising of the Mexican clerical work pool, and our fictional priest would not have stood out as the only ambassador of Satan as a drinker and philanderer during the persecutions, even if he thought of himself in those terms.
 
In fact, he was administering the sacraments, with little fervor but a flickering sense of duty. He charged one peso per confession, probably the custom of the times, and as a man on the run he was not always pleased when a gathering of Catholics materialized wherever he was attempting to sleep, for sacramental access. Yet many of his colleagues had already fled the country. Why hadn’t he left? It was painfully difficult for our priest to understand why he was, at the least, hesitating to flee to safer grounds. But at another level, intellectually he knew exactly what he was doing and why he was doing it.
 
Greene’s genius as a novelist is to penetrate the minds and the consciences of his characters, and here we see the author at his best. The Whiskey Priest did understand the contradictions of his priestly role vis-à-vis his moral degeneracy and present day crisis of faith. As his time grew short, he understood that he might be forgiven by the Almighty, and that in the eyes of local Catholics he might even be thought of as a blessed hero for the Faith. This possibility appalled him, because he was honest enough to know the sinfulness of his life and cynical enough to know that any person considering him a hero in the future was sadly misled. What a dilemma: to seek the forgiveness of God with a subjective doubt that one is unworthy of the gift?
 
There was an actual priest who distinguished himself by courageous sacramental service during the Calles persecutions. He was condemned to death by firing squad, and at the moment of the execution he cried out, “Viva Cristo Rey” or “Long Live Christ the King.” When I was in elementary school we were given holy cards, prayer books, and biographies of this priest, who was canonized by Pope Francis not so many years ago. His name today is St. Miguel Pro. Amazon has many works for readers of all ages on this new saint of the Church.
 
But there is more than a little irony in that a fictional tale of a whiskey priest in the same Mexican persecution, written 84 years ago, as of today sits in the top 1% of all Amazon book sales.
0 Comments

    CATHOLIC NOVELISTS and the BOOKS THEY WRITE

    Archives

    October 2026
    April 2026
    February 2026
    July 2025
    June 2025
    April 2025
    June 2024
    April 2024
    September 2023
    June 2023
    April 2023
    June 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    October 2021

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • HOME
  • MORALITY
  • SCRIPTURE
  • PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
  • CHURCH HISTORY
  • BOOKS
  • LITURGY
  • ON MY MIND
  • The Boys of Aroma Hill-Callicoon
  • ABOUT THE BREWMASTER
  • CATHOLIC NOVELS
  • Book Reviews Adult Education